Tap-Repeatedly
  • Features
    • All Features
    • A Weekend With
    • Dark Souls Diaries
    • Death in Fire
    • Diary Of A Call Girl
    • Games of the Year
    • Kermdinger Chronicles
    • MrLipid’s Closet of the Odd
    • My Idea of Fun
    • Quest for 7:00 on the Nordschleife
    • Superficially Relevant
    • Tap Dance
    • Tap vs. Tap
    • Tapping Down Memory Lane
    • The Log of Shame
  • Editorials
    • Tap Editorials
    • Culture Clash
    • Celebrity Guests
  • Reviews
    • All Reviews
    • Impressions
    • Revisited
    • FFC Archives
  • News
    • News
    • Ephemera
    • Site Announcements
  • Forum

Bioshock 2 Delayed

07/14/2009|Matt "Steerpike" Sakey|News5
Home » Home » News » Bioshock 2 Delayed

steerpike_bioshock2010

Edge – and just about every other news source online – is reporting that Take-Two’s Bioshock 2 has been delayed until 2010, off from its earlier release date of November 2009. As some outlets note, November 2009 is already fiscal 2010 for the publisher, which means that this will not upset the balance sheets, and will probably ensure that Bioshock 2 doesn’t get lost in the holiday release madness.

separator_01To be honest, I don’t have particularly high hopes for Bioshock 2. I don’t expect it to be bad, exactly, I just don’t think it’ll be great. Admittedly my optimism did go up when I learned that the project was being helmed by Jordan Thomas, a longtime freelance level designer and worker with Looking Glass and post-Romero ION Storm. Thomas is not a household name for most gamers, but believe me, you likely know him; he’s the man who designed what’s widely regarded as the most terrifying two hours in gaming: Thief: Deadly Shadows’ shriekedelic Shalebridge Cradle. He also did Fort Frolic from the original Bioshock, a favorite of many gamers, so he hasn’t lost his touch.

Still, and this is just my opinion, I think the team is taking Bioshock 2 in the wrong direction. While it’s obviously necessary to apply some suspension of disbelief in a shooter that takes place in a Randian utopia on the floor of the Atlantic ocean, setting the game a decade after the first – when that one already took place a decade or so after the fall of Rapture – is pushing the limit. One of the important themes of Bioshock was the hubris of building a city underneath the sea, and great care was taken in that game to show that Rapture was being reclaimed by the ocean long before your character arrived.

Making Bioshock 2’s protagonist into a Big Daddy is another misstep, as is the decision to add a new super villain in the form of Big Sister. Why? Because it’s obvious and contrived, and if there’s one thing Bioshock wasn’t, it’s formulaic. Personally I believe the sequel would have been far more interesting if set during the period leading up to and during the civil war that brought about the end of Rapture, possibly with a certain degree of mission-based factionalism allowing your character to choose sides and upset the balance. Since we know how the war comes out, obviously your character wouldn’t be able to change the inevitable outcome, but very few details are actually made known in Bioshock, so the specifics could be altered based on your actions. And also we’d have had seen a narrative rarity in gaming: a protagonist who dies at the end. I’m a sucker for stories in which the protagonist dies at the end.

Anyway, the decision to delay the game is not likely the result of production problems or the need for more time. By all accounts Bioshock 2 is coming along very nicely, on schedule and on budget, though some eyebrows were raised when we learned last week that French developer Arkane – they of Arx Fatalis and Dark Messiah fame – was being brought in to do some work on the game. Arkane brings the total number of studios working on Bioshock 2 to four (!), which is sure to cause some confusion and disconnect. It’s frankly a rather weird setup. While it’s not uncommon to have a second studio work on the multiplayer in a game (as Digital Extremes is doing for Bioshock 2, a game that shouldn’t have multiplayer in the first place), to divide the single-player work among three studios on three separate continents is both odd and indicative of the fact that Take-Two lacks absolute confidence in the developer it chose to lead this title.

Still, it’s much more reasonable to assume that Take-Two simply decided to avoid the crowded holiday season and give 2K Marin a little extra time to buff the game than it is to assume problems, Arkane announcement notwithstanding (who would bring Arkane in to save a troubled project anyway? They’re known for mediocrity, not brilliance). The masterpiece that was Bioshock has fallen somewhat out of favor; like most trailblazers, it’s now regarded as not really blazing much of a trail, because other games have been quick to latch onto its innovations. There’s also the fact that it was never really that innovative, it was just a really good game. Bioshock was a good game but is unlikely to be remembered as an important one, particularly in a year that saw releases like Portal. Bioshock 2 will almost certainly be less of an innovator than even its predecessor was (which doesn’t preclude the possibility of it being a great game), and as such will likely be consigned to the shelf to gather dust shortly after it’s finished by gamers, never to be visited again. Until Bioshock 3.

article_footer

07/14/2009 Matt "Steerpike" Sakey

About the author

Avatar
Matt "Steerpike" Sakey

Tap-Repeatedly Overlord Steerpike is a games industry journalist and consultant. His earliest memories are of video games, and hopes his last memories will be of them as well. He’s a featured monthly columnist with the International Game Developers Association, and is internationally published in an assortment of dull e-Learning texts and less dull gaming publications. He also lectures on games at various universities.

Related Posts

  • The Last of Us Part II: Hateful. Brutal. Beautiful?
    The Last of Us Part II: Hateful. Brutal. Beautiful?07/14/2020
  • Irrationalia
    Irrationalia02/19/2014
  • What a Difference a Year Makes
    What a Difference a Year Makes08/20/2013

Popular Posts

  • Impressions: The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
    Impressions: The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim11/12/2011
  • PC Gaming Diagnosed with Lung Cancer
    PC Gaming Diagnosed with Lung Cancer02/18/2010
  • Impressions: Star Wars: The Old Republic
    Impressions: Star Wars: The Old Republic10/05/2011
← Pony Up for the Kids!
A Failure in Five Fits →

5 Responses to Bioshock 2 Delayed

  • Avatar
    Marquez 07/14/2009

    Your suggestion of a better direction to take the story is fantastic, Steerpike.  I’d love, love, love to play that game.

    The Big Daddy thing is troubling to me for several reasons, one of the foremost of which is that the missions in which you played a Big Daddy were some of my least favorite.  It was meant as an entertaining variation in the original, but really only the variation was entertaining; the actual play was cumbersome and distracting.

    Still, I miss wandering Rapture.  A stunning world, that one.  That and The Zone made me feel more in place than any game had in a long while.

  • Avatar
    Mike "Scout" Gust 07/14/2009

    It does feel like Bioshock is moving in the wrong direction, timewise. I can understand why they are wary of a prequel or giving up plot reveals in favor of filling in backstory. Still, the Bioshock backstory is so compelling and was one of the reasons the game was so good. To just dump that and go for completely new player character gimmicks is sort of puzzling.

    I agree with Marquez. I thought playing a Big Daddy was off setting and claustrophobic.

    I don’t want to be a Big Daddy. There. I said it.

  • Avatar
    Jesrad 07/15/2009

    I hadn’t paid attention to Bioshock 2 at all and actually thought the sequel was going to be a prequel!  Showing the city before it became a waterlogged nightmare would be immensely preferable to traipsing through the same ruined city again. 

    In hindsight, it isn’t surprising that the developers lack innovative ideas for the sequel since the original game was basically System Shock with a fresh coat of paint.

  • Avatar
    Matt "Steerpike" Sakey 07/15/2009

    I can report that the being-a-Big-Daddy thing is pretty much irrelevant – apparently you move like a person and the helmet doesn’t obscure your vision. It’s because you’re the prototype first Big Daddy. It was, um, only with the more advanced models that they got slow and clunky. I guess.

    Jesrad, I agree with you. If the devs are hoping to succeed with “more of the same” here, they may be surprised. Bioshock was lauded as innovative when it first came out, but it has long since settled into that “very good game, but not innovative” category. They’d have done better to take it in another direction. I’m sure we’ll see different areas of Rapture, but that alone may not be enough.

  • Avatar
    ajax19 07/15/2009

    Good.  This may give me time to actually play Bioshock 1.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Log In


Lost your password?
Register
Forgotten Password
Cancel

Register For This Site

A password will be e-mailed to you.


Tap Us

Follow Us on FacebookFollow Us on TwitterFollow Us on YouTubeFollow Us on SteamFollow Us on RSS

Tap At Random

Impressions: Thief

Impressions: Thief

03/05/2014|Tap-Repeatedly|Impressions44

Solar Powered DS Lite

02/12/2009|Mike "Scout" Gust|News3
Adventure Games from Phoenix Online Publishing at GDC

Adventure Games from Phoenix Online Publishing at GDC

03/24/2014|Amanda "AJ" Lange|Impressions3
The Castle Doctrine

The Castle Doctrine

02/11/2014|Gregg B|Impressions, Reviews3
You Go Hide, I’ll Count to Ten

You Go Hide, I’ll Count to Ten

11/29/2011|Matt "Steerpike" Sakey|Ephemera14

Blogroll

  • A Hardy Developer's Journal
  • Acid for Blood
  • Dubious Quality
  • Electron Dance
  • Fanboy Comics
  • Plot is Gameplay's Bitch
  • The Experimental Gameplay Project

Tap Categories

Tap Archives

Follow Us on RSSFollow Us on SteamFollow Us on TwitterFollow Us on YouTube

Tap-Repeatedly finally updated the footer.
Tap-Repeatedly likes oatmeal cookies.
Tap-Repeatedly prefers they have no raisins.

Contact

Your message was successfully sent. Thank You!

Tap-Repeatedly Supports

Search Tap

Tap-Repeatedly Remembers

Brad “Doublesauce” Boivin
Bill “The Game Doctor” Kunkel
Ethan “Finkbug” Sicotte

Copyright © Tap-Repeatedly. All rights reserved. Unauthorized duplication or distribution prohibited.
Some copyrighted material appears on this site under Fair Use.
If you believe a copyrighted work appears inappropriately, please contact steerpike@tap-repeatedly.com.